DON’T MISS
IamExpat FairIamExpat Job BoardIamExpat Webinars
Newsletters
EXPAT INFO
CAREER
HOUSING
EDUCATION
LIFESTYLE
EXPAT SERVICES
NEWS & ARTICLES
Home
Expat Info
German news & articles
Is it time to scrap private health insurance in Germany?
Never miss a thing!Sign up for our weekly newsletters with important news stories, expat events and special offers.
Keep me updated with exclusive offers from partner companies
By signing up, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our privacy policy

Is it time to scrap private health insurance in Germany?

Never miss a thing!Sign up for our weekly newsletters with important news stories, expat events and special offers.
Keep me updated with exclusive offers from partner companies
By signing up, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our privacy policy
or
follow us for regular updates:



Related Stories

April 2025: 8 changes affecting expats in GermanyApril 2025: 8 changes affecting expats in Germany
July 2022: 15 changes affecting expats in GermanyJuly 2022: 15 changes affecting expats in Germany
June 2022: 10 changes affecting expats in GermanyJune 2022: 10 changes affecting expats in Germany
Childless people shouldn’t pay more to pensions and health insurance, court rulesChildless people shouldn’t pay more to pensions and health insurance, court rules
April 2022: 11 changes affecting expats in GermanyApril 2022: 11 changes affecting expats in Germany
2022 in Germany: All of the changes expats need to know about2022 in Germany: All of the changes expats need to know about
December 2021: 9 changes affecting expats in GermanyDecember 2021: 9 changes affecting expats in Germany
October 2021: 9 changes affecting expats in GermanyOctober 2021: 9 changes affecting expats in Germany
For expats of all colours, shapes and sizes

Explore
Expat infoCareerHousingEducationLifestyleExpat servicesNews & articles
About us
IamExpat MediaAdvertisePost a jobContact usImpressumSitemapRSS feeds
More IamExpat
IamExpat Job BoardIamExpat HousingIamExpat FairWebinarsNewsletters
Privacy
Terms of usePrivacy policyCookiesAvoiding scams

Never miss a thing!Sign up for expat events, news & offers, delivered once a week.
Keep me updated with exclusive offers from partner companies
By signing up, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our privacy policy


© 2025 IamExpat Media B.V.
© 2025 IamExpat Media B.V.
Feb 18, 2020
Abi Carter

Editor in chief at IamExpat Media

Abi studied German and History at the University of Manchester and has since lived in Berlin, Hamburg and Utrecht, working since 2017 as a writer, editor and content marketeer. Although she's happily taken on some German and Dutch quirks, she keeps a stash of Yorkshire Tea on hand, because nowhere does a brew quite like home.Read more

If all citizens were covered by statutory health insurance, contributions to social security would sink dramatically. That’s according to a new representative study, conducted by the Berlin-based Iges Institute on behalf of the Bertelsmann Foundation, which was published on Monday. 

Scrapping private health insurance could save 10,6 billion euros per year

According to the report’s authors, if everyone in Germany currently covered by private health insurance (PKV) were to switch to state insurance (GKV), each person currently covered by GKV - and their employers - could save an average of 145 euros per year. 

The report argues this on the basis that privately insured persons - people commanding high salaries, civil servants and entrepreneurs - earn at least 56 percent more, on average, than those covered by state insurance. They also tend to be healthier.

If they were instead covered by statutory health insurance, the German health insurance system could hypothetically bag an additional 38,6 billion euros per year in premiums. Adjusting for additional expenditure, this would bring in a net financial surplus of 8,7 to 10,6 billion euros each year, allowing the government to reduce the contribution rate by 0,6 to 0,7 percentage points.

However, the remuneration for doctors is approximately 2,5 times higher for private patients than statutory ones. If doctors were compensated for loss of fees, the study’s simulation calculates that the contribution rate could still be lowered by 0,2 to 0,3 percentage points. Then GKV-insured people and their employers would be relieved by 48 euros per year, on average. 

The study is based on the latest data (2016) from an annual repeat survey of around 12.000 households. In 2016, around 8,8 million people in Germany were privately insured, compared with the approximately 70,4 million insured by the GKV. 

Germany’s dual insurance system weakens social cohesion?

Overall, the Bertelsmann Foundation warned that Germany’s dual system threatened to erode solidarity and weaken social cohesion. The Foundation’s health expert, Stefan Etgeton, criticised the fact that, “The average [GKV] insured person pays more than necessary every year so that high-income earners, civil servants and the self-employed can avoid solidarity compensation. 

The Foundation is therefore calling for a change to health insurance and long-term care insurance, to make it easier to switch from private health insurance to statutory health insurance. They argue that contributions should be based on income, not on individual risks. 

The civil service association dbb, on the other hand, emphasised that Germany’s dual health insurance system is “lived solidarity”. Dbb boss Ulrich Silberbach dismissed the abolition of the dual system as “nonsense”, arguing instead that “Our healthcare system is one of the best in the world.”

Last year, the state health insurance system in Germany recorded a loss for the first time since 2014, of around one billion euros. 

By Abi Carter